Taking too long? Close loading screen.

Reporting about the clashes between Israeli shepherds and Palestinians, as well as Israeli farms and agricultural settlements, obscures what is actually taking place in the West Bank


One of the most disturbing episodes of violence this year involving Israelis and Palestinians in the West Bank took place on Friday. There was a clash outside the Palestinian village of Burqa that resulted in the death of Palestinian Qusai Jamal Matan, the hospitalization of Israeli Yehiel Indore, the arrest of Indore and Elisha Yered—who was until recently the spokesperson for Otzma Yehudit MK Limor Son Har-Melech—and the arrest of five Palestinians. Precisely what took place is still being investigated, and each side has its own version of the alleged facts. What is not in dispute is that an Israeli shepherd from the illegal outpost of Oz Zion was grazing his sheep on private Palestinian land belonging to Burqa residents when he was confronted by Palestinians from Burqa. Rather than calling the IDF or the police, the shepherd called his friends from Oz Zion and other settlements for reinforcements. When fighting broke out between the two sides, Indore shot and killed Matan. Indore—who is from Ofra, a settlement largely built illegally on private Palestinian land that was later retroactively legalized—was seriously injured by a rock to the head, and Yered—who is from the illegal outpost Ramat Migron—is alleged to have hidden Indore’s gun after the shooting in an effort to obstruct the investigation.

Ofra settlement, May 26, 2011 by יעקב, licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 (License linked to image) 

At some point the police and the courts will determine who threw the literal first stone, whether Indore killed Matan before or after he was injured, and why MKs from the coalition have been allowed to visit and confer with Indore in the hospital despite him being under active investigation. But what should jump out immediately is that the Israelis involved were all from communities in the West Bank that were established illegally under Israeli law, remain illegal under Israeli law (with the exception of parts of Ofra), and that the fighting broke out because of an Israeli with a flock of sheep who was on private Palestinian land that did not belong to him. This fact pattern is increasingly being repeated across the West Bank, and it is not a coincidence. To understand the exponential jump in settler violence, it is critical to recognize its intimate and direct connection to illegal settlement outposts and illegal agricultural outposts. Violence coming from these outposts is a feature, not a bug; their purpose is to confront Palestinians in violent ways and prevent any type of Palestinian sovereignty in the future.

As outlined in Israel Policy Forum’s new report on U.S. policy toward settlements, there are more illegal settlements and agricultural outposts in the West Bank—approximately 145 and 80, respectively—than legal settlements, of which there are 127. More than 50 of the agricultural outposts have been established since 2017. What makes all of these illegal are that they have not been authorized by the Israeli government nor gone through the required planning and zoning process. Instead, they have been erected illegally, often in the dead of night as a way of avoiding detection. Settlement outposts are often built on private Palestinian land, another element that makes them illegal, and tend to be clustered along the major transportation arteries. They are also often built close to existing settlements so that they can be dubbed as neighborhoods of legal settlements, making them appear less controversial and giving them a patina of legality, which also makes it easier to retroactively legalize them down the road. Ramat Migron, where Yered hails from, is an illegal settlement outpost built on land privately owned by Palestinians from Burqa that has been demolished and rebuilt ten times, and is the descendant of Migron, another illegal outpost built on private Palestinian land that was evacuated and demolished in 2012 following a high-profile court order to do so. Oz Zion, which is where the Israelis who got into a confrontation with the Palestinians in Burqa set out from, has been demolished and rebuilt at least four times, and sits just north of Burqa and next to Givat Asaf, another and larger illegal outpost.

Flag of Oz Zion., February 17, 2012 by יעקב, licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 (License linked to image)

Illegal agricultural outposts—which have a few families or individuals at best—tend to be even smaller than illegal settlement outposts, which are sometimes only a handful of people but can also be tens of families. They tend to be built on state or survey land and are almost always in close proximity to Palestinian villages. The idea behind agricultural outposts is that they are an easy and low-cost way to take over large quantities of land by using them for grazing or planting crops but without needing to have a large population living there or build many structures, thereby establishing facts on the ground and preventing Palestinians from using the land. Once an agricultural outpost is created, the ostensible farmers or shepherds who live there usually begin to not only take over the state and survey land in the area, but encroach on private Palestinian land from neighboring Palestinian villages as well. Employing violence in the form of beating Palestinian farmers and shepherds, burning their crops, cutting down their olive trees, and stealing their sheep is not uncommon and is done in an effort to get the local Palestinians to vacate their land in the face of constant attacks and harassment. The 80 or so agricultural outposts and the land they control encompass 4% of the West Bank alone despite having a population of less than 1,000 people, which demonstrates why this has become a favorite method of the more extremist wing of the settlement enterprise.

This context sheds some light on how events like last Friday’s unfold. The settlers who live in Oz Zion created an illegal community, defied the Israeli government and IDF multiple times by rebuilding their illegal community after it was demolished according to Israel’s laws, and are flouting any semblance of the rule of law by continuing to live there. The same goes for Yered, who lives in one of the most notorious illegal outposts. When asked last month by Yisrael Hayom about the violent reprisal attacks on Palestinian villages that are unconnected to terrorist attacks, he said that “in war, you don’t fight against individuals – you fight against an enemy, and against an enemy, there is also collective punishment.” And this is someone who still somehow worked as a Knesset aide for a current MK who is part of Israel’s ruling coalition. These illegal outposts are purposely placed next to Palestinian villages, and their purpose once there is to do everything they can to harass the Palestinians living there. 

Illegal outpost of Oz Zion, December 30, 2011 by יעקב, licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 (License linked to image)

Keep all of this in mind the next time you read a story about Israeli shepherds, who seem to coincidentally be grazing their sheep on land privately owned by Palestinians, and coincidentally are accompanied by friends with guns—including a friend who is a long-time Shin Bet target—and coincidentally all live in illegal outposts, and coincidentally don’t call the IDF or police until after Palestinians have been assaulted and Palestinian agricultural land has been burned. I have no way of knowing for sure what actually led to an injured Israeli and a dead Palestinian last week outside of Burqa, but I do know that a shepherd is often not just a shepherd.

Subscribe To Our Mailing List
We respect your privacy.

Privacy Preference Center