Yes You Can, Mr. President

The views shared on The Mideast Peace Pulse are those of the author(s) and not those of Israel Policy Forum.

Israel Policy Forum Announces its Next Chapter with Middle East Progress

Dear Friends and Supporters of Israel Policy Forum:

On behalf of Israel Policy Forum (IPF), including our President Peter Joseph and Chair Larry Zicklin, I am pleased to inform you that IPF is embarking on its next chapter. 

2010 Must Be Showtime for Mideast Peace

Assistant Director, IPF - NY

As 2009 draws to a close, we are bombarded by the annual litany of commentary features recapping the year in Hollywood movies to the year in international conflict, and everything in between.

When it comes to the Middle East peace process, current conventional wisdom suggests the 2009 recap might go something like this: 

US-Iran Negotiations: Simulation Exercise at INSS

Ephraim Asculai, Emily B. Landau, and Tamar Malz-Ginzburg

INSS Insight No. 154, December 29, 2009

Despite the tendency to denote any simulation exercise on security issues a "war game," the recent simulation designed and held at INSS did not focus on the option of a military attack. Rather, it developed the scenario of a bilateral US-Iranian negotiation over Iran's nuclear program.

Tags

Gaza Fire: Israeli analysis of war's outcome, "we're screwed."

"Unfortunately, we're back to the starting point," Shaar Hanegev Council Chairman Alon Schuster, told Yediot Acharonoth, after a grad rocket fell in a courtyard of the synagogue yesterday in Netivot.

Israel resumed air attacks on Gaza, targeting and assassinating three members of the Islamic Jihad and smuggling tunnels on the border.

Yediot Acharonoth:

In the course of the day, eight Kassam rockets, one Grad rocket and two mortar shells were fired at southern communities, and the IAF bombed arms smuggling tunnels in the Philadelphi Road area several times.  A security official described the situation as a "deadlock," and said that the new government would have to make critical decisions regarding the Gaza Strip.


Ma'ariv:

"We've reached a deadlock," a high-ranking security official said.

"We are busy with 'maintenance' work in order to pass the time as quickly as possible until the formation of a new government, which will have to make critical decisions about the Gaza Strip."

Analysis: Israel's operation in Gaza is now a proven failure, according to Yediot Acharonoth columnist Nahum Barnea:

Operation Cast Lead in Gaza was intended to restore the Israeli deterrence vis-à-vis Hamas and create new rules of the game in the south.  Unfortunately, it failed miserably in achieving these two goals.  Hamas did not soften and was not deterred.  The arms smuggling was renewed and the rocket fire has continued.  The residents of Gaza are now perceived by the world as victims of Israeli vindictiveness.  The United States and European Union are applying pressure to open the crossings and are raising money for rebuilding what was ruined.  Egypt is working to form a Palestinian unity government, a move that may be good for Israel in the long term but is a bad sign in the short term.

In brief, we're screwed.

 

Since the operation ended a month and a half ago, Yediot Acharonoth military analyst Alex Fishman wrote:

The IDF has carried out approximately 70 attacks of various kinds in the Gaza Strip, most of them blowing up tunnels from the air and very few of them targeted killings. All this has been in response to the firing of approximately 110 rockets and mortar shells at Israel by the small terrorist groups that operate in the Gaza Strip. Officials in the IDF and the security establishment believe that as of now, there is no justification to go to more aggressive levels of response. They say that this balance is more reasonable.

Today, no security agency is recommending a return to Gaza for an operation like Operation Cast Lead to the political echelon. IDF officials insist that Hamas is not interested in a rematch. So it is true that it is not preventing other organizations from shooting, and it is true that some of the rockets that were fired at Israel by Fatah were manufactured in Hamas workshops-but, as IDF officials continue to claim firmly, Hamas's supreme interest today is still quiet in the Gaza Strip.

Hamas operatives understood that the current government in Israel would not accede to their demands in the Gilad Shalit case, and that a tahdia agreement would not move forward anytime soon either. So they decided to direct most of their resources toward obtaining international recognition and controlling the millions that will soon begin to stream in for the reconstruction of Gaza in the wake of the conference in Sharm el-Sheikh.

But a lack of a mechanism (a Palestinian unity government) to get money to Gaza without empowering Hamas, has stalled the rebuilding Gaza's and the easing of the suffering of its people.

 

 

Trackback URL: http://israelpolicyforum.org/trackback/1071

Comments

toadys IPF letter on GAZA Operation and "3 conditions"

Lately IPF has really wriiten more balanced articles including the Arabs' inability to even recognize Israel...  Those watching Pres. Peres' debate at Davos with Turkey's PM (which caused him to walk out) saw the reality that has set in finally with Peres. Pres. Peres who implemented various pro Arab programs and an Arab Doctor in every Israeli hospital was screamimng" what do u want from us, after giving back GAZA?"He see the shortcomings of his peaceful vision due to Hamas' vision of hate!

I believe that the focus of IPF on  balanced approach will make the ARABS realize 'Israel is here to stay and is willing to make surviaval insuring land compromisises,"   All of Israel must realize that the Palestinians are  here to stay and reasonable compromises that gives both sides their dignity and survival insurance are necessary for all.   Israel did give back all of Lebanese land and all of Gaza, as the UN verified. The UN has stated both times "Israel is 100% compliant of returning everything both times",  What did they get in return? Over 1000 Israelis dead since the Intifada started what differnce does it make if it took 7 years or  7 days as in GAZA.
This balanced IPF approach  helps both sides realize where they have gone astray. In some chassidic synagouges , chassidim now enjoy your recent articles.